What Is a Utah Domestic Relations Commissioner, and How Does a Commissioner Differ from a Judge?

If you file a divorce, child support, or parentage action in Utah, you may discover that your case has both a judge and a “domestic relations commissioner” assigned to it.…

Continue ReadingWhat Is a Utah Domestic Relations Commissioner, and How Does a Commissioner Differ from a Judge?

Pearson v. Pearson – 2026 UT App 169

Unequal Property Division in Utah Divorce Pearson v. Pearson addresses unequal property division in Utah divorce, including the requirement to assess both spouses’ circumstances before dividing marital property unequally. The…

Continue ReadingPearson v. Pearson – 2026 UT App 169

What Is a Utah Domestic Relations Commissioner, and How Does a Commissioner Differ from a Judge?

If you file a divorce, child support, or parentage action in Utah, you may discover that your case has both a judge and a domestic relations commissioner assigned to it.…

Continue ReadingWhat Is a Utah Domestic Relations Commissioner, and How Does a Commissioner Differ from a Judge?

What Kind of Lawyer Does a Complicated Child Custody Case Require?

What kind of attorney do you need when you're involved in a complicated, contentious child custody dispute? An experienced attorney? An aggressive attorney? An attorney who promises to fight for…

Continue ReadingWhat Kind of Lawyer Does a Complicated Child Custody Case Require?

No Custody Order, No Visits: What Can You Do in Utah?

"We don't have a custody order or a child support order. My child's other parent won't let me pick him up or spend birthdays or holidays with him. What can…

Continue ReadingNo Custody Order, No Visits: What Can You Do in Utah?

The Marital Division of Labor Was Not a Child Custody Audition

A family's division of labor does not establish a hierarchy of parenthood. That should be obvious, but custody disputes often proceed as though it were not. One parent may have…

Continue ReadingThe Marital Division of Labor Was Not a Child Custody Audition

Why Doesn’t Utah Have a Divorce and Child Custody Rocket Docket?

Why should an ordinary divorce or child custody dispute take a year or longer to resolve? "These cases are complicated" is an explanation for some cases. It is not an…

Continue ReadingWhy Doesn’t Utah Have a Divorce and Child Custody Rocket Docket?

Utah Family Courts: When Lying Works, Expect More of It

Courts do not cause people to lie in divorce and child custody disputes. Courts do, however, have enormous influence over whether lying works. That distinction matters. Most people do not…

Continue ReadingUtah Family Courts: When Lying Works, Expect More of It

When a Court-Ordered Alcohol Evaluation Can’t Say No

Suppose two people have the same drinking habits. Both drink socially, occasionally overdo it, hold steady jobs, and have no pattern of alcohol-related impairment. One consults a professional on his…

Continue ReadingWhen a Court-Ordered Alcohol Evaluation Can’t Say No

Utah Family Law Needs a Subtractive Audit

In 2021, researchers at the University of Virginia published a study in Nature built around a Lego structure (Adams, Converse, Hales, and Klotz). Participants had to stabilize a platform so…

Continue ReadingUtah Family Law Needs a Subtractive Audit

In Utah Family Law, Delay Is Not Neutral

Family litigation takes time. Some delay is inevitable and some is justified. Judges have crowded calendars. Lawyers have conflicting trials. Discovery takes time. Serious child-safety allegations may require investigation before…

Continue ReadingIn Utah Family Law, Delay Is Not Neutral

Proffer Hearings in Utah Family Court: When a Disputed Fact Requires Actual Evidence

Summary: Proffers save time by letting lawyers tell the court what witnesses would say. That works well when the parties agree to proceed that way or when the court assumes…

Continue ReadingProffer Hearings in Utah Family Court: When a Disputed Fact Requires Actual Evidence

How Divorce Clients Sabotage Their Own Cases: The Mistakes That Actually Matter

Executive Summary: Most divorce cases are not damaged because clients lack legal knowledge. They are damaged by avoidable mistakes in judgment: hiding bad facts, treating suspicion as proof, creating damaging…

Continue ReadingHow Divorce Clients Sabotage Their Own Cases: The Mistakes That Actually Matter

Let Two Fit Parents Share Equal Time. A Defiant Teenager Is the Best Reason Why.

"Mom, why are you only setting one place for dinner tonight?" "Because your dinner’s at Dad's house tonight. It's your night with him tonight, and I know he's got dinner…

Continue ReadingLet Two Fit Parents Share Equal Time. A Defiant Teenager Is the Best Reason Why.

The Arrest Is Not Really the Evidence: Probable Cause and Domestic Relations Cases

A parent tells the police that the other parent assaulted her. An officer responds, interviews people at the scene, and arrests the accused parent. Weeks later, the parties are in…

Continue ReadingThe Arrest Is Not Really the Evidence: Probable Cause and Domestic Relations Cases

Child Parent-Time Refusal in Utah: How Courts Tell “Can’t” from “Won’t” (“I can’t make them” is where the inquiry starts)

"Why hasn't your son been to his father's home since March?" "He's sixteen. I can't make him." Sometimes that answer is true. Sometimes it's the end of a long, ugly…

Continue ReadingChild Parent-Time Refusal in Utah: How Courts Tell “Can’t” from “Won’t” (“I can’t make them” is where the inquiry starts)

Can You Ask the Court to Test the Custody Schedule You Are Proposing?

Suppose you are asking for joint or equal physical child custody. The other parent opposes it. Why not ask the court to put your proposed schedule into effect temporarily so…

Continue ReadingCan You Ask the Court to Test the Custody Schedule You Are Proposing?

The Answer to Too Much Psychology in Child Custody Disputes Is Not Reflexively More Psychology

Summary. Family law increasingly describes ordinary misconduct in clinical terms. Selfishness becomes narcissism, and disagreement becomes gaslighting. When amateur psychology complicates a child custody dispute, courts and lawyers often respond…

Continue ReadingThe Answer to Too Much Psychology in Child Custody Disputes Is Not Reflexively More Psychology

The First Draft Is the Fitting, Not the Finished Suit

Executive Summary: I draft legal documents the way a tailor fits a suit. I start with a proven structure, show the client an actual draft, and then adjust the approach,…

Continue ReadingThe First Draft Is the Fitting, Not the Finished Suit

Neither Spock Nor McCoy: What Administering Utah Family Law Actually Requires

Disraeli said never apologize for feeling, because to do so is to apologize for truth. He was right, and Utah family law should take him seriously. A parent's fear for…

Continue ReadingNeither Spock Nor McCoy: What Administering Utah Family Law Actually Requires

Who Gets the Benefit of the Doubt? What the Lindsay Clancy Case Can Teach Utah Family Courts

The Lindsay Clancy murder trial is about as far removed from an ordinary Utah divorce case as one can imagine. Clancy admitted killing her three young children in Massachusetts in…

Continue ReadingWho Gets the Benefit of the Doubt? What the Lindsay Clancy Case Can Teach Utah Family Courts

When “Erring on the Side of Caution” Becomes a Substitute for Proof

There is a powerful argument for caution in family court, and it deserves to be taken seriously. When a judge or commissioner is confronted with an allegation that a parent…

Continue ReadingWhen “Erring on the Side of Caution” Becomes a Substitute for Proof

If a PGAL Can Interview a Child, So Can a Judge or Commissioner

Utah Courts Should Stop Paying an Intermediary to Tell the Factfinder What the Factfinder Can Hear Directly When a child's wishes, concerns, experiences, or perceptions matter in a Utah child…

Continue ReadingIf a PGAL Can Interview a Child, So Can a Judge or Commissioner

Guanuna v. Sawatzki: Utah Court Upholds Presumed Father Despite DNA

2026 UT App 130 THE UTAH COURT OF APPEALS JUAN MIGUEL GUANUNA, Appellant, v. LINDSEY R. SAWATZKI AND JONATHAN C. SAWATZKI, Appellees. Opinion No. 20240191-CA Filed August 20, 2026 Third…

Continue ReadingGuanuna v. Sawatzki: Utah Court Upholds Presumed Father Despite DNA

The “Noble Exit” Trap: How Moving Out Can Reshape a Child Custody Case Before It Begins

It often begins with a request that sounds perfectly reasonable. “We need some space.” “The fighting isn’t good for the kids.” “Why don’t you stay somewhere else for a while…

Continue ReadingThe “Noble Exit” Trap: How Moving Out Can Reshape a Child Custody Case Before It Begins

The Performative Care Trap: Why Family Court Is Addicted to Therapy

There is a ritual that plays out with remarkable regularity in Utah family court proceedings. A divorce becomes ugly. A parent is angry. A child is anxious. Communication deteriorates. Someone…

Continue ReadingThe Performative Care Trap: Why Family Court Is Addicted to Therapy

When “Special Training” Becomes a Credentialist Dodge

What “Special Training” Does a Judge Really Need to Talk to a Child? In Utah child custody disputes, one of the stock objections to having a judge interview a child…

Continue ReadingWhen “Special Training” Becomes a Credentialist Dodge

Let the Judge Talk to the Child. Have the Judge Talk to the Child

One of the strangest objections to judges interviewing children in child custody disputes is that the interview might make the child anxious. Of course it might. The child’s parents are…

Continue ReadingLet the Judge Talk to the Child. Have the Judge Talk to the Child

When (and Why) Cheap Therapy Culture Makes Family Law Worse

Mental-health awareness has helped people recognize genuine illness, obtain treatment, and speak about suffering without shame. That is real progress. But family law increasingly reveals the other side of the…

Continue ReadingWhen (and Why) Cheap Therapy Culture Makes Family Law Worse

Public Comment on Proposed Utah Rule of Civil Procedure 110 — Judicial Interview of a Minor Child

Summary: 1. Proposed paragraph (b)(2) applies to judicial interviews substantially the same restrictive threshold the Legislature imposed on compelled child testimony. 2. Concerns about litigation abuse and judicial workload justify…

Continue ReadingPublic Comment on Proposed Utah Rule of Civil Procedure 110 — Judicial Interview of a Minor Child

When a Label Changes the Past: Testing Memory Instead of Trusting It in Custody Disputes

Here is the objection this post is going to draw, so I deal with it directly instead of dodging it: raising questions about the reliability of memory sounds like it's…

Continue ReadingWhen a Label Changes the Past: Testing Memory Instead of Trusting It in Custody Disputes

Kids Don’t Belong in the Driver’s Seat: How Utah Custody Law Rewards Defiance and Calls It Protection

A fit parent is awarded equal custody of two teenagers. Nothing in the record suggests that parent is dangerous, neglectful, or unfit—the court has already said so. A few months…

Continue ReadingKids Don’t Belong in the Driver’s Seat: How Utah Custody Law Rewards Defiance and Calls It Protection

Your Therapist May Need a Second Opinion Too

I recently encountered a Facebook Reel that is funnier—and probably truer—than many people will be comfortable admitting. Watch the original Reel here. The Reel’s creator identifies what she calls the…

Continue ReadingYour Therapist May Need a Second Opinion Too

You Don’t Want an Overworked Judge or Domestic Relations Commissioner Deciding Your Family’s Fate

Judge Kasey Wright deserves more credit than ridicule for refusing to pretend that chronic triage is competent judging. On July 13, 2026, Utah Fourth Judicial District Judge Kasey Wright submitted…

Continue ReadingYou Don’t Want an Overworked Judge or Domestic Relations Commissioner Deciding Your Family’s Fate

When the Old Lame Excuses Fail, New Ones Will Be Invented

Judges in child custody disputes should hear from children more often. A lot more often. It should be routine, the presumptive course, the default. Not because children should decide custody…

Continue ReadingWhen the Old Lame Excuses Fail, New Ones Will Be Invented

“I’m Not Trained to Interview Children” and Other Empty Objections Behind Utah’s PGAL Default

At a recent hearing, a commissioner explained why she was appointing a private guardian ad litem instead of interviewing the child herself: "Given the age of the child, the statutory…

Continue Reading“I’m Not Trained to Interview Children” and Other Empty Objections Behind Utah’s PGAL Default

One Opinion, Seven Letterheads: The Family Court Echo Chamber

Christine Miller recently made a point about family court that deserves more attention: the appearance of independent professional agreement where no genuine independence exists. When a court appoints a private guardian…

Continue ReadingOne Opinion, Seven Letterheads: The Family Court Echo Chamber

Kids Don’t Belong in the Driver’s Seat: How Utah Custody Law Rewards Defiance and Calls It Protection

A fit parent is awarded equal custody of two teenagers. Nothing in the record suggests he's dangerous, neglectful, or unfit—the court has already said so. A few months in, the…

Continue ReadingKids Don’t Belong in the Driver’s Seat: How Utah Custody Law Rewards Defiance and Calls It Protection

The Weaponization of Victimhood: A Candid Look at the Inexcusable Bias in Family Courts

“A woman's greatest strength [in divorce court] is her ability to be a victim.” It’s a statement that immediately makes people boil over—either in furious agreement or absolute outrage. But…

Continue ReadingThe Weaponization of Victimhood: A Candid Look at the Inexcusable Bias in Family Courts

Let. The. Evidence. Point. The. Way.

A recent podcast clip I saw this week made a deliberately provocative claim: “A woman’s greatest strength is her ability to be a victim.” Taken literally, the statement is too…

Continue ReadingLet. The. Evidence. Point. The. Way.

When Family Courts Punish the Innocent Parent

Child Custody Defiance Should Not Cost a Fit Parent Both the Children and More Money Suppose a court orders equal custody. Both parents are fit. One parent is ready, willing,…

Continue ReadingWhen Family Courts Punish the Innocent Parent

The Intersection of Federal Immigration Law and Utah Divorce

One of the most complex, high-stakes scenarios occurs when federal immigration policies collide head-on with state domestic relations law. Under the federal Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), a non-citizen spouse…

Continue ReadingThe Intersection of Federal Immigration Law and Utah Divorce

SB 304 Promised a Fix for Weaponized Protective Orders. Read the Statute

Anyone who practices Utah family law has watched it happen. A child custody dispute is going badly for one parent, or hasn't started yet, and a protective order petition appears.…

Continue ReadingSB 304 Promised a Fix for Weaponized Protective Orders. Read the Statute

Protection Without Prejudice

A temporary protective order should do one thing well: protect against the danger actually alleged and shown by nothing less than a preponderance of the evidence. It should not become…

Continue ReadingProtection Without Prejudice

The Bloodletting of Family Law: When the System Mistakes Itself for the Cure

For centuries, physicians bled their patients and called it medicine. The patients got weaker; the doctors, confident in their training, prescribed more bleeding. Medicine now has a name for harm…

Continue ReadingThe Bloodletting of Family Law: When the System Mistakes Itself for the Cure

Make Honesty the Selfish Move

Designing divorce and custody settlements that resist gaming Most child custody disputes — and most of the financial fights that ride alongside them — run on bad incentives. The system…

Continue ReadingMake Honesty the Selfish Move

When Courts Reward What They Could Stop the Result Are Always Tragic

I don’t have all the facts about this. None of us do at this point. And what facts we have may not even be fully “factual,” but we’ve seen this…

Continue ReadingWhen Courts Reward What They Could Stop the Result Are Always Tragic

When an “Absent” Parent Was Pushed Out

When a parent isn't active in a child's life, most people think they already know why. He must not care. She must have checked out. He must have wanted something…

Continue ReadingWhen an “Absent” Parent Was Pushed Out

The Hard Truth About Grandparents’ Visitation “Rights”

Utah grandparent visitation rights can be court-ordered, but they are hard to win. A grandparent can ask a Utah court for visitation, but Utah law starts with a strong presumption in…

Continue ReadingThe Hard Truth About Grandparents’ Visitation “Rights”